«

»

Sep 20 2009

Education Comparison in Australian Schools

A common comment is that the primary education is different here in Australia when compared to the UK.

A number of people have said that children here are allowed to be children for longer, no real pressure on direct learning, but lots of encouragement in learning to learn and enjoying school.

More involvement in school and class dramas, plays etc. Learning to be social etc.

As a direct age comparison, I have read that UK children are further ahead academically, but that Australian children are more ahead in being a person.

This can change when they move to High School, and by the end of their schooling, it seems to even itself out.

International Education Survey Comparisons

There are two International Education surveys carried out on a regular basis; PISA and TIMSS.

Both of these surveys provide information about different aspects of students’ mathematics and science learning.

  • PISA assesses careful reading, logical thinking and the application of general mathematical and scientific processes and principles to everyday problems.
  • TIMSS assesses mastery of the factual and procedural knowledge taught in school mathematics and science curricula.

By comparing the PISA and the TIMMS results, it would seem that the following applies:

  • Australia and New Zealand students perform better (on average) in applying general mathematical and scientific principles and skills to everyday problems than in recalling and using curriculum-based factual and procedural knowledge.
  • UK students perform better (on average) in recalling and using curriculum-based factual and procedural knowledge, compared to the application of these skills in everyday situations.

PISA 2006 World rankings for Reading, Maths and Science
An article in the Daily Telegraph in December 2007 showed the rankings of 57 countries in the subjects of Reading, Maths & Science.

  • In Reading, the UK was position 17, with Australia at position 7
  • In Maths, the UK was position 24, and Australia at position 13
  • In Science, the UK was position 14, and Australia at position 8.

The data comes from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).

There is another article also at the Daily Telegraph with more information.

More information on the UK – Australia comparisons, from the: PISA 2006 Results PDF File

Science Proficiency

  • 563 Finland – The Highest Scoring country
  • 527 Australia – Position 8
  • 515 United Kingdom – Position 14

Reading Proficiency

  • 556 Korea – The Highest Scoring country
  • 513 Australia – Position 7
  • 495 United Kingdom – Position 17

Mathematics Proficiency

  • 549 Chinese Taipei – The Highest Scoring country
  • 520 Australia – Position 13
  • 495 United Kingdom- Position 24

TIMSS 2007

TIMMS (Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study) is a worldwide research project, taking place every four years and providing data about trends in Mathematics and Science achievement over time.

A total of 36 countries at Year 4, and 49 countries at Year 8, participated in the TIMSS 2007 study, with approximately 425,000 pupils involved worldwide.

Most countries tested pupils with 4 years formal schooling, but England and Scotland tested year 5 pupils.

  • In Australia 228 schools and 4,108 students participated in year 4, with 228 schools and 4,069 students in year 8.
  • In Scotland 139 schools and 3,929 students participated in year 5, with 129 schools and 3,929 students in year 9 (P5).
  • In England 143 schools and 4,316 students participated in year 5, with 137 schools and 4,025 students in year 9.

Note: TIMSS  assesses the knowledge and skills of pupils aged 9-10 (otherwise known as grade 4.) and 13-14 (grade 8. ). Both England and Scotland entered year 5 and year 9 children, whilst the other countries entered year 4 and year 8.

The results can be seen at:

A few examples of this report, based on this following Points System,

  • 625 Advanced benchmark
  • 550 High benchmark
  • 475 Intermediate benchmark
  • 400 Low benchmark

are:

Actual score Results:

  • Primary Mathematics
    • 541 England Year 5
    • 516 Australia Year 4
    • 494 Scotland Year 5
  • Primary Science
    • 542 England Year 5
    • 527 Australia Year 4
    • 500 Scotland Year 5
  • Senior Mathematics
    • 513 England Year 9
    • 496 Australia Year 8
    • 487 Scotland Year 9
  • Senior Science
    • 542 England Year 9
    • 515 Australia Year 8
    • 496 Scotland Year 9

Year 4 Mathematics

Australia’s score has increased by 17 since 2003 and by 22 score points since 1995.

Australia’s year 4 was outperformed in 2007 by England’s year 5, but was higher than Scotland’s year 5.

Students in Year 4 who spoke a language other than English at home achieved significantly lower on average in mathematics than students who predominantly spoke English.

Year 8 Science

Australia’s average score has declined by 12 points since TIMSS 2003, and is relatively unchanged since 1995.

Australia’s year8 was outperformed by England’s year 9, but came ahead of Scotland’s year 9.

The proportion of students achieving the advanced benchmark was strikingly higher for students with at least one parent completing a university degree.

Australian students tend to receive less mathematics and science homework at both Year 4 and Year 8 than students in other countries.

There is a difference between the States with ages of the children participating, with the lowest year 4 average age group being 9.5 yrs (QLD) and the highest being 10.3 yrs (TAS).

This is due to different school starting ages in the different States.

The results for Queensland are consequently lower than most other States.

There is a PDF document with all the results, and sample questions, which makes very interesting for anyone interested in the Education in Australia.

The document is here:



1 - 716

Win a Luxurious home in Australia with Hometown Prize Draws.

For Books with Free Delivery to Australia, look at: BookDepository UK and USA

1 comment

  1. ABCDiamond

    Pisa 2009 figures can be seen at: http://stats.oecd.org/PISA2009Profiles

    and at: http://www.pisa.oecd.org/dataoecd/54/12/46643496.pdf

    These results show the following:

    PISA 2009 results in the three subjects.

      Rank Reading Score
      1 shanghai-China 556
      2 Korea 539
      3 Finland 536
      6 Canada 524
      7 New Zealand 521
      9 Australia 515
      17 United States 500
      25 United Kingdom 494
      Rank Maths Score
      1 shanghai-China 600
      2 singapore 562
      3 Hong Kong-China 555
      10 Canada 527
      13 New Zealand 519
      15 Australia 514
      29 United Kingdom 492
      32 United States 487
      Rank Science Score
      1 shanghai-China 575
      2 Finland 554
      3 Hong Kong-China 549
      7 New Zealand 532
      8 Canada 529
      10 Australia 527
      16 United Kingdom 514
      23 United States 502

Leave a Reply to this Posting, but no links please.